5 Best Ways to Reheat Pizza Like New
Everyone loves pizza, but unless you are one of the crazy people who enjoy eating it cold, you have probably reheated it.
While some people just want it warm and in their belly, there are definitely some better ways to go about it.
We found the absolute best ways to reheat pizza to prevent it from getting too soggy, dry, or hard.
In this article, we will cover each of the best ways to reheat your pizza like new using the 5 common heating methods available.
Table of Contents
You may also like these other pizza articles:
How to Reheat Pizza in the Oven
The best way to reheat pizza in the oven is to first line a baking sheet with foil and preheat it with the oven at 350ºF. Once the oven and pan are fully heated, you add your slices of pizza and cook for 5-10 minutes. Once it is cooked to how you like it, carefully remove the pan and enjoy your pizza.
For more clarification, here are the detailed steps.
To Perfectly Reheat Pizza in the Oven:
Step 1: Preheat the Oven to 350ºF
Step 2: Line a metal baking sheet with foil and put it in the oven.
The idea is that you want to warm up the pan to get it hot before adding the pizza.
Just let the pan preheat with the oven.
Step 3: Put the pizza in the oven for 5-10 minutes.
Put the pizza directly on your pan with foil and let it bake for 5-10 minutes while checking on it periodically to avoid burning.
Carefully remove the hot pan to enjoy the crispy slices of pizza.
NOTE: If the pizza you are trying to reheat is already super hard, you may consider rubbing a small amount of cooking oil, and even a few drops of water, on the crust with your finger or paper towel before heating.
How to Reheat Pizza in the Microwave
The best way to reheat pizza in the microwave is with a glass of water inside with a paper towel between the pizza and plate. Having a glass of water in the microwave will help the pizza cook more evenly and not get zapped. For one pizza slice with regular crust, 30-45 seconds will usually get it to the right temperature.
The crust of most leftover pizza will be dry and hard. The glass of water heats up and puts moisture in the air that the crust can absorb.
To Perfectly Reheat Pizza in the Microwave:
Step 1: Put a paper towel on a plate, then put your slice of pizza on top of it.
The paper towel helps absorb excess moisture and grease as well as help prevent sogginess.
Parchment paper or a paper plate could also be used.
Step 2: Get a small glass of water and put it in the microwave with your pizza.
The glass of water will absorb much of the microwave's energy and allow the pizza to cook slower and more evenly.
This really works and prevents certain parts of the pizza from overcooking while some parts are still cold.
Step 3: Heat for 30-45 seconds based on how big of a slice of pizza you have.
You can use this method to reheat multiple slices of pizza at a time, but it works best if you do one at a time.
For best results, microwave 15-20 seconds intervals to ensure you get it just how you want it.
How to Reheat Pizza on the Stove
The best way to reheat pizza on a stove is with a non-stick skillet that has a lid. You preheat the pan, add the pizza, and cook it on medium heat for a few minutes uncovered. Then add a few drops off water to the pan (not the pizza) and cook for another minute, covered.
Here are the more detailed steps to help revitalize your leftover pizza slices in a pan.
To Perfectly Reheat Pizza on the Stove:
Step 1: Preheat the skillet on medium heat for 1-2 minutes.
Heating the pan before adding ingredients is always a good idea as it helps prevent sticking.
You can also add just a few drops of oil if the pizza is quite dry.
Step 2: Add a slice or two of pizza to the pan, and cook for 2 minutes.
Warm the pizza for 2 minutes in the pan.
If it starts to burn, simply lower the heat and move to the next step.
Step 3: Add a few drops of water to the pan, cover the pan and cook for 1 minute.
You add the water and cover immediately to trap the moisture and steam melt the cheese.
This water-adding trick not only melts the cheese to perfection but also will help rehydrate dry crust.
How to Reheat Pizza in a Toaster Oven
The best way to reheat pizza in the toaster oven is to cook one slice at a time at 350ºF. Cook the pizza directly on the rack for 3-5 minutes, depending on the size and thickness. When it is heated, and the cheese is melted, carefully remove and enjoy.
Here are the more detailed steps.
To Perfectly Reheat Pizza in a Toaster Oven:
Step 1: Preheat the toaster oven to 350ºF.
Step 2: Place your pizza directly on the rack and bake for 3-5 minutes.
Again, if the pizza is super dry or hard you may consider rubbing just a few drops of water on the crust before cooking.
Step 3: When done, remove the pizza carefully with a spatula or tongs.
Transfer the pizza from toaster oven to plate and enjoy!
How to Reheat Pizza on the Grill
The best way to reheat pizza on the grill is to cook it straight on the grill grate on medium heat for 5-6 minutes. You want to preheat the grill before adding the pizza and then check on it every few minutes. Once it is cooked to your liking, safely transfer the pizza from grill to plate.
To Perfectly Reheat Pizza on a Grill:
Step 1: Fire up the grill and preheat to medium heat.
Step 2: Set a few slices of pizza directly on the grate and cook for 5-6 minutes
This is assuming your grill grate is clean; if not, you may want to clean it first.
Make sure to check on the pizza a few times while it is cooking to be safe.
Step 3: When done, carefully remove the pizza with a spatula or tongs.
Safely transfer your pizza to your plate and enjoy it once again.
What is the Absolute Best Way to Reheat Pizza?
The quickest and most efficient way to reheat pizza is using the microwave method with a glass of water. We know the microwave is always the fastest, but this method also helps improve the quality of the pizza. Let's face it, most people aren't going to be patient enough to use the other methods, so just improving the microwaved quality is very beneficial.
The method that produces the highest quality of reheated pizza is the oven method with the preheated pan and foil. Nothing beats a little patience and heating the pizza up the same way it was born. This method is great for a couple of slices, and the toaster oven will do close to the same quality if you are just looking to heat up one slice.
The most underrated pizza reheating method is the pizza on the stove method. This method will be a little faster than the oven method and can really help the crust of day-old pizza. Also, this method gets the cheese just right for those that love it a little gooey. The pizza on the grill method is not far behind this but usually a little less accessible for most people.
Try these out and let us know which one you like best!
If this made you hungry and you want to make your own pizza, check out our recipe for The Perfect Homemade Pizza Dough!